John Passant

Site menu:

 

February 2010
M T W T F S S
« Jan    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728

Tags

Archives

Authors

Site search

Miniposts

Labor - making the Liberals look good
The Coalition has overtaken the Labor Government on primary votes in the latest Newspoll. Labor – making the Liberals look good. (0)

Alistair Hulett - another great socialist dies
Alistair Hulett - singer, songwriter, socialist – died overnight. Chris Harman, Daniel Bensaid, Howard Zinn and now Alistair. Farewell comrades. (1)

Let's give one million pounds to Goldman Sachs!
Goldman Sachs has agreed to limit its UK partners’ pay and bonuses to 1 million pounds. That sounds about right - one million pounds into their money grubbing greedy guts. (0)

McGorry backtracks
Australian of the Year Professor Patrick McGorry has backtracked from his recent comment that detention centres are breeding grounds for mental illness. He now says he was criticising past government policies. Ah, that explains it. Howard and Keating detention centres bad; Rudd detention centres good. Shame, McGorry, shame. (0)

White Australia has a black history
White Australia has a Black History 6 pm Thursday 4 February Room G 31 Copland Building Australian National University. Socialist Alternative Canberra. (0)

Happy Invasion Day 2010
A great video about invasion day on 26 January. (0)

Moderation, comments and the like
Dear Readers, sometimes your post might get held up for moderation. This might be because it comes from a source often identified with spam, or contains words that are often used in spam.  And to avoid late spam I have cut down the time for comments to be made to a week from publication. Because I work it means I do not always get to look at the moderation queue immediately. So it might take some time for your comment to appear. If it is commenting on an article more that a week old it won’t appear. Finally a combination of work and a certain medical issue may see me posting less material in the coming months. (Stop that cheering!) We shall see. (0)

Australia's imperialist Antarctic claims
According to the Australian Antarctic Division website: Australian Antarctic Territory covers nearly 5.9 million square kilometres, about 42% of Antarctica and nearly 80% of the total area of Australia itself. In addition Australian claims that ‘the Australian Antarctic territorial waters extend 200 nautical miles out to sea from the Australian Antarctic territory.’ Only 4 countries recognise our (imperialist) Antarctic claims. Japan does not. I think that crimes on the high seas – Australia won’t push the idea that the ramming of the Ady Gil occurred in Australian territorial waters – fall under the jurisdiction of the country in which the relevant ship is flagged. In this case that is likely to be New Zealand. (1)

I've been blaired - hallelujah
Ah, I wondered why some fairly reactionary and inane comments were on my blog piece on cricket and conservatism. I believe Tim Blair from News Ltd has mentioned (and presumably attacked) me on his blog for previewing (or perhaps predicting?) the result of the second test. Actually I stayed away from that and was arguing that Australian cricket was too conservative and that would lead to its further decline. The win over Pakistan in Sydney only masks that. (0)

Warning: bad joke
Margaret Thatcher went to dinner with her male Cabinet. ‘Steak or fish?’ the waiter asked. ‘Steak of course,’ she replied. ‘And what about the vegetables?’ ‘They’ll have steak too.’  With thanks to the Australian Financial Review. (0)

Advertisement

Links:

Gunga Din: who is Rudd talking about?

The Committee to Humanise Our Prime Minister (CHOPM) has excelled itself this time. 

Poor old Therese Rein had the shits  – who wouldn’t with a husband like Kevin? – and spent a night in Cairns Hospital.  

As she left the hospital the Prime Minister reassured all of us about his wife’s health.

She’s made of sterner stuff than you or I, Gunga Din ….

So now we’ve moved on from shaking the sauce bottle to Gunga Din. 

It just sounds so false coming out of the mouth of a nerd like Rudd. 

CHOPM really should desist and let Rudd talk about what he knows – you know, things like detailed programmatic specificity.

But once again, like fair shake of the sauce bottle, CHOPM couldn’t even get the saying right.

So who is this Gunga Din?

The words come from the racist ‘poet’ of empire – Rudyard Kipling. It’s about a bhisti ( a lower caste water carrier for households or soldiers in the times of the British Raj ) who sacrifices his life for a British soldier.  The final verse of Gunga Din says:

Though I’ve belted you and flayed you,
By the livin’ Gawd that made you,
You’re a better man than I am, Gunga Din!

Gunga Din delivered water to the British soldier and saved his life just before he himself was killed.  Gunga Din is almost a ‘white man’.

So Rudd is saying his wife is a good bhisti?  Hmm.  Not good but a view that probably deep down reflects his attitude to women.

Just as Kipling’s soldier was surprised by the courage of Gunga Din (and his loyalty to Empire’s thugs) so Rudd is surprised by Rein’s ability to overcome diarrhoea and her loyalty to him and his rotten Labor Government.

She’d take  a bullet for God, King and Country and for Kevin (who epitomises all the values of the British Raj).

More likely, Rudd is talking about you and me. He thinks we are the lower orders, ready to die for our superiors (like him and Therese). Not me boyo but as Afghanistan worsens and more Australian men and women die for the US alliance apparently I am in the minority.

Lest I be accused of over-analysing this, (God forbid!), he was also saying his wife was strong and had recovered, unlike poor Gunga Din who died for imperialism.

Advertisement

Comments

Pingback from “Gunga Din”? What was Rudd on about? | Opinions.com.au
Time August 10, 2009 at 7:49 am

[...] More here: “Gunga Din”? What was Rudd on about? [...]

Comment from Matt
Time August 12, 2009 at 3:45 pm

Really, John, you are over-analysing this comment. Too much time and (perhaps) anti-Rudd animus I suspect.

Comment from John
Time August 12, 2009 at 7:54 pm

Matt you are right about over-analysing , but I just wanted to have a bit of fun and chase up Kipling again. My most viewed and googled article was the one on Rudd’s comment about detailed programmatic specificity and I thought there might be a few enquiries about who Gunga Din was as well.

And surely CHOPM has a ring of truth about it, don’t you think? Or if not truth, possibility? That tells us something about how we (or maybe just it’s just me) feel about Rudd.

I look forward to Rudd’s next

Comment from John
Time August 12, 2009 at 7:56 pm

Oops. I got sidetracked and didn’t finish my last comment. I look forward to Rudd’s next Delphic announcement, one that needs deciphering.